Diminished Value
Can I Claim Diminished Value If the Other Driver Was at Fault?
By The CCA Team
Short answer: Often, yes. When another driver caused the crash, a diminished value claim is generally made against that driver’s liability insurer, not your own policy. Diminished value is the market value your vehicle can lose even after a quality repair. Rules vary by state, so confirm yours and document the loss before you settle.
Why isn’t a good repair the end of the loss?
A repair fixes the car. It does not fix the history. The next buyer, or the next dealer you trade with, can see a collision on the record, and that can change what they are willing to pay. The shop can do perfect work and the market can still pay less than it would have the week before the crash.
That gap is the loss. If the other driver caused it, the question is who answers for it and how you ask. Start with our explainer, What Is Diminished Value?
What is diminished value, in one sentence?
Diminished value is the difference between what your vehicle was worth immediately before the accident (the date of loss) and what it is worth after it has been repaired. It is a market question, not a repair question. A repair bill shows what the work cost, not what the car is worth now. See how diminished value is calculated for more.
Why does fault change who you claim against?
Because fault decides which policy is in play.
- First-party claim: you ask your own insurer to pay under your own policy. What that policy covers depends on its wording and on your state.
- Third-party claim: you ask the at-fault driver’s liability insurer to pay for the damage that driver caused. You have no contract with that insurer, so you are presenting a claim, not invoking your policy.
The Texas Department of Insurance draws this same line. In Bulletin B-0027-00 it says an insurer is not obligated to pay a first party claimant for diminished value when a vehicle is completely repaired to its pre-damage condition, and then adds that an insurer “also may be obligated to pay a third party claimant for any loss of market value of the claimant’s automobile, regardless of the completeness of the repair, in a liability claim that the third party claimant may have against a policyholder.”
That is Texas. Other states have their own rules. For the broader picture, see Can I File a Diminished Value Claim? and first-party versus third-party claims.
What does a third-party diminished value claim usually need?
A number alone is not a claim. Gather these while the file is fresh:
- The repair file. The final repair invoice, photos before and after, and any notes about structural or frame work.
- Vehicle details. Year, make, model, trim, mileage at the date of loss, and your service records.
- The before value. What the vehicle was worth immediately before the accident, as of the date of loss, supported by comparable listings or sales.
- The after value. What the vehicle is worth now that it carries a collision history, supported the same way.
- A written demand. Put the request in writing, attach the proof, and keep a copy of everything you send and receive.
A clear, supported file gives the adjuster something to evaluate. For an independent opinion on the numbers, read Do I Need a Diminished Value Appraiser?
Do the rules change in Arizona, Ohio, Texas, Florida, and Georgia?
Yes. Whether a diminished value claim can be made, how it is measured, what proof is expected, and how long you have to bring it all vary by state. We do not repeat deadlines or formulas here because they can change. Start with the CCA page for your state:
- How to file a diminished value claim in Arizona and the Arizona diminished value overview
- How to file in Ohio and the Ohio overview
- How to file in Texas and the Texas overview
- How to file in Florida and the Florida overview
- How to file in Georgia and the Georgia overview
Then confirm the current rule with your state insurance department: the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions, the Ohio Department of Insurance, the Texas Department of Insurance, the Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Consumer Services, or the Georgia Office of Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner. For a legal question about your claim or a deadline, talk with an attorney in your state.
CCA is based in Gilbert, Arizona, and works with vehicle owners in the Phoenix metro and nationwide.
What does it cost to wait or to sign too soon?
Time limits apply to property damage claims, and they vary by state. Waiting costs you the chance to document the loss while the evidence is fresh. Signing too soon can cost more: once a release is signed, that conversation may be over. Read Should I Sign a Release Before I Know My Diminished Value? before any paper goes back.
Also read our list of 7 mistakes that kill a diminished value claim before you talk to anyone.
What is a sensible next step?
Gather the file now, while the claim is open. Our free Diminished Value Guide is on our free guides page.
Then find out what your claim could be worth. No pressure: enter your information on our website to see what your claim could be worth, then pick the appraisal that fits, or schedule a free claim review. You can also call Charlie at (877) 587-3040, Monday to Friday, 9 to 5, or use our contact page.
CCA offers two paths. A Report only gives you an independent, documented valuation. A Report with Claim Support adds demand letters, communication help, and coaching. It is not us negotiating for you. More detail is on our diminished value services page.
The recap is simple. Fault decides who you claim against. Document the before value, the after value, and the repair. Check your state’s rules. Do not sign anything until you know what it closes.
Collision Claims Advisors. Certified appraisers. 25+ years in collision.
Frequently asked questions
Can I claim diminished value if the other driver was at fault?
Often, yes. A third-party diminished value claim is generally presented to the at-fault driver’s liability insurer. Rules vary by state, so confirm yours with your state insurance department and the CCA page for your state.
Do I file with my insurer or the other driver’s insurer?
When another driver is at fault, the claim for the loss that driver caused generally goes to that driver’s liability insurer. Whether your own policy covers it depends on its wording and your state.
What proof helps a diminished value claim?
The final repair invoice, before and after photos, service records, mileage at the date of loss, and comparable listings or sales that support the before value and the after value. Put your request in writing and keep copies.
Does Texas treat a third-party claim differently from a first-party claim?
Yes. In Bulletin B-0027-00, the Texas Department of Insurance says an insurer may be obligated to pay a third party claimant for any loss of market value, regardless of the completeness of the repair. It treats first party claims differently.
Do Arizona, Ohio, Texas, Florida, and Georgia all handle this the same way?
No. Whether you can claim, how the loss is measured, and how long you have all vary by state. Start with the CCA state page that matches you, then confirm the current rule with your state insurance department.
How can CCA help?
Enter your information on the CCA website to see what your claim could be worth, then pick the appraisal that fits (Report only, or Report with Claim Support) or schedule a free claim review. You can also call Charlie at (877) 587-3040.